4.6
(10)
190
riders
23
rides
Best touring cycling routes Shelter Island Heights offer a diverse landscape for exploration. The island features a mix of green hills, sandy beaches, and dense woods, with nearly one-third dedicated to preserves like Mashomack Nature Preserve. Cycling routes often follow well-paved roads, though some sections may include sandy gravel. The region's 20 miles of coastline provide varied views of Peconic Bay and Gardiners Bay.
Last updated: July 16, 2026
5.0
(1)
39
riders
55.4km
03:26
330m
330m
Moderate bike ride. Good fitness required. Mostly paved surfaces. Suitable for all skill levels.
5.0
(1)
16
riders
32.0km
01:58
170m
170m
Moderate bike ride. Good fitness required. Mostly paved surfaces. Suitable for all skill levels.

Sign up for free
4.0
(1)
21
riders
47.9km
02:43
120m
120m
Moderate bike ride. Good fitness required. Mostly paved surfaces. Suitable for all skill levels.
4.5
(2)
18
riders
23.7km
01:25
150m
150m
Moderate bike ride. Good fitness required. Mostly paved surfaces. Suitable for all skill levels.
17
riders
44.6km
02:38
260m
260m
Moderate bike ride. Good fitness required. Mostly paved surfaces. Suitable for all skill levels.
Get access to more routes and recommendations from other explorers.
Sign up for free
Already have an account?
Our route recommendations are based on thousands of hikes, rides, and runs completed by other people on komoot.
Start today with a free account
Your next adventure awaits.
Login or Signup
Popular around Shelter Island Heights
Nice State Park with a swim beach, hiking trails, picnic area, snack bar, great birding, etc.
0
0
You will find a medium-sized paved parking lot off of Deerfield Road, with access to the Paumanok Path and the Noyac Hills County Park trail system.
0
0
A save beach, and one of a lot one Long Island
0
0
Nice little beach out towards the end of the North Fork of Long Island. The "sand" is actually more rock so bare feet might get a bit sore. The sunsets can be incredible on the right day.
1
0
Hashamomuck Beach, composed of sand and shells, sits just off Highway 48. It provides a picturesque spot for enjoying sunsets or sunrises. Visitors can enjoy the sound of small, crashing waves and make use of the ample parking.
0
0
The Water Mill Windmill at 695 Montauk Highway in Water Mill, New York, holds historical significance as a tangible link to the area's past. Erected in the 18th century, it stands as an iconic reminder of early milling practices, showcasing traditional craftsmanship and serving as a testament to the region's agricultural and industrial history.
0
0
Orient Beach is a small, beautiful beach on a narrow strip of land on Orient Point. The beach is part of Orient Beach State Park and a must visit if in the area.
0
0
There are over 25 touring cycling routes available in Shelter Island Heights, catering to various skill levels. This includes 14 easy routes, 13 moderate routes, and 1 difficult route, ensuring options for every cyclist.
Cyclists can expect a diverse landscape, including green hills, majestic beaches, and dense woods. Most routes follow well-paved roads, but some sections, like the spur to Shell Beach, may feature sandy gravel. The island's extensive preserves, such as Mashomack Nature Preserve, offer varied natural beauty.
Yes, Shelter Island Heights offers several easy touring cycling routes suitable for families. For example, the Shelter Island Heights loop from Village of Dering Harbor is an easy 23.6 km (14.7 miles) route that takes approximately 1 hour 26 minutes, providing a pleasant experience for all ages.
Many routes offer breathtaking views of Peconic Bay and Gardiners Bay. You can also explore historic architecture in areas like "The Heights" with its gingerbread cottages, or visit landmarks such as Shelter Island Heights itself. The Mashomack Preserve is another significant natural attraction along some routes.
Yes, many touring cycling routes in Shelter Island Heights are circular, allowing you to start and end at the same point. A popular moderate option is the Shelter Island Heights loop from Shelter Island Heights, which covers 35.7 km (22.2 miles) and offers coastal and wooded sections.
The touring cycling routes in Shelter Island Heights are highly rated by the komoot community, with an average score of 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 10 reviews. Cyclists often praise the diverse terrain, from green hills to coastal paths, and the well-maintained roads that make for an enjoyable ride.
Shelter Island is primarily accessed by ferry. You can take a ferry to the island with your bicycle, which is a popular way to start a touring cycling adventure. It's advisable to check the ferry schedules in advance.
Parking is generally available at various points around Shelter Island Heights, especially near ferry terminals or public access areas. Many cyclists opt to take the ferry to the island and begin their tour directly from there, eliminating the need for car parking on the island itself.
Absolutely. A significant portion of Shelter Island is preserved land. The Mashomack Nature Preserve, covering 2,000 acres, is a prime example, offering rich habitats and natural beauty. Other preserves like Mildred Flower Hird Nature Preserve and Crab Creek Preserve also contribute to the island's abundant natural areas, where you might spot blue herons or ospreys.
For a moderate route exploring the island's interior, consider the Shelter Island Heights – Dickerson Creek loop from Shelter Island. This 42.5 km (26.4 miles) route takes approximately 2 hours 36 minutes and offers varied terrain through the heart of the island.
Yes, you can find routes that lead through coastal landscapes and natural preserves. The Hashamomuck Beach – Orient Beach State Park loop from Southold is a moderate 47.9 km (29.8 miles) trail that takes about 2 hours 43 minutes, offering views of coastal areas and leading to a state park.
Maps of Shelter Island's walkable open space and preserved land, which can be helpful for cyclists, are often available locally. You can also check resources like the official town website for more information: shelterislandtown.gov/266/Maps-Trails.


Browse the best Cycling routes in other regions.