Best attractions and places to see around Brewster Hill, New York, encompass a mix of natural features, historical sites, and recreational areas. This hamlet in Putnam County provides access to scenic trails, reservoirs, and cultural points of interest. The region is characterized by its natural beauty, including lakes and woodlands, alongside landmarks reflecting its local history. Visitors can explore a variety of outdoor activities and historical insights within and around Brewster Hill.
Last updated: July 6, 2026
Highlight (Segment) • Trail
Tip by
Highlight (Segment) • Lake
Tip by
Sign up now to discover places like this
Get recommendations on the best single tracks, peaks, & plenty of other exciting outdoor places.
Sign up for free
Highlight • Viewpoint
Tip by
Highlight • Monument
Tip by
Start today with a free account
Your next adventure awaits.
Login or Signup
Climb to the top of the fire tower to get great panoramic views of the surrounding hills, including Stockholm Hill and the Little and Big Buck mountains. This is a great spot!
0
0
Amazing stretch of the EST! Passing the lake and along side old train tracks, wide open skies await you while passing on the trail through 'the great swamps'.
0
0
A scenic road cycling segment. Cars go quite fast and the shoulder is not wide enough, so be careful!
1
0
Incredibly steep dirt road leads to the top but the views from the top of the tower are well worth it.
0
0
The area around Brewster Hill offers several natural attractions. You can visit Tonetta Lake for swimming and a sandy beach, or explore the scenic Putnam Trailway, which follows a former railroad corridor past picturesque lakes and reservoirs. Other natural areas include the Middle Branch Reservoir, Diverting Reservoir, Fred Dill Wildlife Sanctuary, and the Titicus Reservoir North Side, known for its scenic road cycling.
Yes, Brewster Hill and the broader Southeast area are rich in history. You can explore the Southeast Museum, housed in the historic 1896 Old Town Hall, which details local history. The Walter Brewster House, built around 1850, offers tours, and the Old Southeast Church (1794) is the oldest place of worship in Putnam County. The Tilly Foster Mine, once a booming iron mine, is now part of Tilly Foster Farm, offering educational experiences. You can also find numerous historic homes like the Stonehenge-Howes Residence and Yale House.
Beyond exploring attractions, you can engage in various outdoor activities. The Maybrook Trailway is excellent for cycling and walking, offering wide-open skies and passing lakes. The Putnam Trailway is another paved option for pedestrians and cyclists. For panoramic views, climb to the top of the fire tower at Mount Nimham. Fishing is also possible at reservoirs like the Middle Branch Reservoir.
Absolutely. The Maybrook Trailway is categorized as family-friendly, offering an accessible outdoor experience. Tonetta Lake provides a beach for family swimming during the season. Tilly Foster Farm offers entertainment, dining, and educational experiences with animals, which can be enjoyable for families. Additionally, the Brewster Ice Arena offers public skating sessions and lessons.
For breathtaking panoramic views, head to Mount Nimham. Climbing to the top of its fire tower provides excellent vistas of the surrounding hills, including Stockholm Hill and the Little and Big Buck mountains. The Titicus Reservoir North Side also offers scenic views, particularly for those enjoying a road cycling segment.
Yes, the area is well-suited for cycling and running. The Putnam Trailway is a 12-mile paved trail perfect for both activities. The Maybrook Trailway is another popular option, part of the Empire State Trail, offering scenic stretches. For more specific routes, you can find various road cycling and running routes around Brewster Hill, including options like the 'Maybrook Trailway – Whaley Lake loop' or 'Empire State Trail: Hudson Valley Loop'. You can explore these routes further on the Road Cycling Routes around Brewster Hill or Running Trails around Brewster Hill guide pages.
Brewster Hill features several architecturally significant homes. The Stonehenge-Howes Residence on Brewster Hill Road is noted for its eclectic mix of Queen Anne, Tudoresque, and Romanesque styles. The Yale House, also on Brewster Hill Road, is an excellent example of a Greek Revival farmhouse. The Walter Brewster House is another prominent Greek Revival style home. Many other historic residences, such as the Reed-Bloomer House and Seth Howes Home, are recognized as local landmarks throughout the Southeast area.
The primary place to delve into local history is the Southeast Museum. Located in the historic 1896 Old Town Hall in Brewster, it features exhibits on the Harlem Line Railroad, Borden Milk Condensery, Tilly Foster Mine, and the American Circus, providing a comprehensive look at the region's past.
Yes, the Fred Dill Wildlife Sanctuary is a local spot dedicated to wildlife viewing and enjoying nature. Additionally, areas like Wonder Lake State Park, Bloomerside Preserve, and William Clough Preserve offer further opportunities to appreciate the local environment and potentially spot wildlife.
The Putnam Trailway is a 12-mile paved trail that follows a former railroad corridor. It's ideal for pedestrians and cyclists, offering a scenic journey through shady hardwoods and past picturesque lakes like Mahopac, Casse, and Gleneida. You can enjoy long walks, bike rides, and even encounter some challenging steep climbs along its path.
Visitors frequently praise the scenic beauty and diverse outdoor opportunities. The Maybrook Trailway is highlighted as an 'amazing stretch' with 'wide open skies' and views of lakes and old train tracks. The panoramic views from the fire tower at Mount Nimham are also a favorite, offering stunning vistas of the surrounding hills.
Beyond historical sites, you can find cultural and entertainment options. The Brewster Ice Arena offers indoor skating. For a unique experience, the Bull & Barrel Brewpub provides artisanal craft beers and features a mechanical bull. Nearby, the Caramoor Center for Music & Arts in Katonah hosts live music, special events, and historic tours. The Studio Around the Corner, located with the Southeast Museum, is another venue for arts and entertainment.


Still not found the Highlight you’re looking for? See guides of the top attractions in other regions: